‘Pathetic Fallacy’ Review: A Wild, Weird, and Emotional Trip in 35mm (Fantastic Fest 26′)
Adam Egypt Mortimer’s Pathetic Fallacy is the kind of movie that makes you question whether you are watching a horror film, a musical, a love story, a fever dream, or all four at the same time. After seeing it myself, I can happily confirm it is a beautiful mix of them all. With that being said, it instantly became my favorite film from the Fantastic Fest lineup that I got to catch.
Pathetic Fallacy Review: 9/10

Screenshot by Reel Movie Junkie
The film stars Scott Mescudi, better known as Kid Cudi, and Jessica Rothe as it follows Asher and Iris, a couple whose love story is established almost immediately. Their relationship feels genuine, warm, and lived-in, which makes what happens next hit even harder. Iris becomes terminally ill and eventually dies, leaving Asher completely shattered.
From there, the movie takes a hard left turn as Asher travels to the mysterious Mount Samdi, a strange place somewhere between reality and fantasy where grief, death, and desire seem to operate by their own rules. What begins as a desperate attempt to reconnect with Iris quickly becomes a bizarre journey involving murderers, supernatural forces, talking animals, and a very memorable spider voiced by Natasha Lyonne.
Mortimer has created a movie that is intentionally difficult to explain. The further Asher travels into Mount Samdi, the less interested Pathetic Fallacy becomes in traditional storytelling. Instead, the film operates on emotion.
Why Watch
It wants you to understand Asher’s grief rather than simply understand every strange thing happening around him. You will find yourself wondering if you would go to the lengths he does to be reunited with the love of your life after their death.
That approach will not work for everyone, as there are moments when the movie becomes so committed to its bizarre visual language that the story starts to feel like it is slipping away. The psychedelic imagery, talking creatures, musical sequences, and increasingly violent encounters can feel like several different movies fighting for space. But that’s what makes Pathetic Fallacy so dope: the chaos becomes part of the experience.
The biggest reason the movie holds together is Scott Mescudi. Asher could have easily become an exaggerated version of the grieving husband, but Mescudi gives the character a vulnerability that keeps the story grounded. His performance moves from quiet heartbreak to rage, confusion, and desperation without losing the humanity underneath it.
The Cast & Performances

Screenshot by Reel Movie Junkie
Along the way, you might even forget that Mescudi is one of the biggest names in rap culture, as his performance is phenomenal. We need him in more flicks because he strongly commits to any role I’ve seen him in to date.
Jessica Rothe also makes a strong impression. Even though Iris’ time in the story is limited, Rothe gives the relationship enough personality and chemistry to make Asher’s loss believable. You understand why he is willing to go to such extreme lengths to get her back.
Overall Rating: 9/10

Screenshot by Reel Movie Junkie
Pathetic Fallacy looks incredible, mainly due to being shot in 35mm. The film leans heavily into vibrant colors, surreal imagery, and practical and visual effects to create the strange world of Mount Samdi. It feels less like a traditional horror movie and more like someone turned a nightmare into a music video. It plays like a psychedelic trip on shrooms at times.
The music is another major piece of the experience. Mescudi and Rothe contribute original songs, while Johnny Jewel provides the score. The musical elements do not simply exist for style. They become another way for the characters to express emotions that the dialogue cannot fully capture.
At its core, Pathetic Fallacy is about grief and the lengths people will go to avoid accepting loss. Mortimer takes that familiar idea and pushes it into some wonderfully strange places. It’s strange, violent, funny, heartbreaking, and completely committed to its own identity. It won’t be for everyone, but if you are willing to embrace the madness, there is a lot to appreciate here.
Pathetic Fallacy is not a movie you simply watch; it’s one you experience.


